DTJ Legacy Financial · Retirement illustration

Plan conversions.
Account for distributions.

Compare bracket-filling Roth conversions against no conversions, with annual required minimum distributions and Social Security taxation calculated separately for each path.

Educational federal model for one living IRA owner, using the IRS Uniform Lifetime Table. Not for inherited IRAs or an owner whose sole beneficiary is a spouse more than 10 years younger. Review assumptions and limitations before relying on results.

Your assumptions

Tax and planning assumptions

Automatic: birth years 1951–1958 → age 73; 1960 onward → age 75. For 1959, choose a manual age after confirming applicable guidance. This tool models one owner’s traditional IRAs, not a combined spousal IRA.

Social Security

RMD cash-flow treatment

RMDs are assumed fully taxable and paid in their required calendar year. First-year April 1 deferral, QCDs, inherited IRAs, and the younger-spouse joint-life table are not modeled.

Future brackets and the entered deduction grow from 2026 using your inflation assumption. Future tables are projections, not enacted law. The default deduction is basic only; adjust it for your circumstances.

Projected after-tax asset difference
—

Total converted—
Conversion-related federal tax—
With conversions: ending assets—
No conversions: ending assets—
Total RMDs: conversion path—
Total RMDs: no conversions—

Ending assets = Roth + traditional IRA after your terminal tax haircut + outside savings. The haircut is a simplified valuation, not a simulated liquidation tax return.

Projected after-tax assets

Conversions + RMDsNo conversions + RMDs

Plan notes

Annual RMD, conversion, and tax schedule

P = conversion plan; B = no-conversion baseline. Scroll horizontally for all columns; the CSV includes complete balances and taxes for both paths.

YearAgeRMD factorRMD PRMD BGross SSTaxable SS P before conversionTaxable SS P after conversionTaxable SS BConversionConversion taxRMD tax PRMD tax BTaxable income PIRA PRoth PCash PAssets PAssets B
RMD and tax calculation methodology

For each year at or beyond the selected RMD start age: RMD = preceding December 31 traditional IRA balance ÷ the IRS Uniform Lifetime Table factor for the owner’s attained age. The initial IRA input represents the preceding December 31 value. Subsequent years use each strategy’s own prior ending balance. Roth IRAs have no owner lifetime RMD in this model.

The RMD is withdrawn first and is never eligible for conversion. It is added to ordinary income before calculating taxable Social Security and bracket room. Federal tax attributable to the RMD equals tax with the RMD minus tax on the same other income and benefits without the RMD. That incremental tax is paid from the RMD proceeds; net proceeds are either reinvested or excluded as spending, according to your selection.

Next, the solver recalculates taxable Social Security at every candidate conversion and finds the largest cent-rounded conversion below the target taxable-income ceiling, annual cap, remaining IRA balance, and outside-cash tax budget. Conversion tax equals federal tax after conversion minus federal tax after the RMD but before conversion. Available tax cash includes reinvested net RMD proceeds.

RMDs, conversions, and associated tax payments occur at the start of each year; all remaining balances then earn one annual return. Both paths calculate their own RMDs, Social Security taxation, and RMD taxes. No-conversion RMDs do not reuse the conversion path’s balances.

Social Security, tax tables, and cash-flow assumptions

Provisional income is other ordinary income + RMD + conversion + tax-exempt interest + half of gross Social Security. Joint thresholds are $32,000/$44,000; single thresholds are $25,000/$34,000. Up to 85% of benefits may become taxable. These thresholds do not grow with the bracket-inflation input.

Federal progressive ordinary-income brackets and basic deductions are based on IRS 2026 values for single and joint returns. The entered deduction is a 2026 amount, inflated to each modeled year. Additional age-based deductions, income-sensitive deductions and credits are not automatic. Income and benefits are assumed spent; baseline federal tax on non-RMD income is assumed paid from that income outside the modeled assets.

Outside savings returns are entered net of taxes and do not automatically enter provisional income. Enter other taxable income and tax-exempt interest consistently with your own cash-flow assumptions. Both paths begin with identical assets. When net RMDs are spent rather than reinvested, spending differs between paths; the displayed result compares remaining assets only, not total lifetime consumption. The CSV reports cumulative net RMD spending separately.

Unsupported cases and limitations

Not a complete retirement or tax-return model. No QCDs, first-RMD deferral, missed prior distributions, inherited IRAs, multiple owners’ IRA balances, younger-spouse Joint Life Table, nondeductible basis/pro-rata rules, state tax, IRMAA, NIIT, AMT, preferential capital-gain tax, Social Security repayments/lump-sum elections, credits, penalties, or spending-needs optimization. Roth withdrawals are assumed eventually qualified. Birth years before 1951 are outside the supported cohort range; age 120 and above uses the table’s 120+ factor of 2.0. Accounts are not modeled beyond death.

If your spouse is the sole beneficiary and more than 10 years younger, the required table differs; do not use this calculator’s Uniform Lifetime result. For birth year 1959, automatic selection is intentionally disabled: verify the applicable start-age rule and use an override. Any manual override is your responsibility.

IRS sources: Publication 590-B and Uniform Lifetime Table · RMD comparison chart · Social Security taxation · 2026 federal tax adjustments.

Want to see what this could mean for your own plan?

This calculator shows the mechanics. A conversation shows what fits your situation, your taxes, and your family.

Talk It Through With Deah
Explore more from DTJ Legacy: DTJ Legacy Financial · Texas life insurance quotes · Insurance 101 guide · Dallas–Fort Worth real estate